Hot News - Old, Interesting

To Deliver Real Senate Rule Changes, Repeal The 17th Amendment

2 22


There is certainly one individual I know that is going to love this story, one who posted the idea of repealing the 17th Amendment in a comment on The Brown Dispatch quite some time ago, and one who should credit for this excellent proposition…Angus Rangus!

Can you imagine a more functional Senate with Senators that are actually responsible and responsive to its state’s citizens?  Brilliant!


Last week President Trump tweeted that Senate rules for budget bills should be changed. There’s little chance that will happen. But why settle for little changes when we need big-league change? We need to stop playing the game as it has always been played. If we’re to get this country back on track, we need to change the rules of the game.

Much of the frustration with Washington DC has been building for decades, and for good reason. People feel cut out and abandoned by their government. Government plays an even larger role in their lives and takes even more money out of their pockets, but they aren’t seeing many benefits. They feel they’ve been cut out by their party and its elites, whom they fund.

We’re staring $20,000,000,000,000 in debt, and it’s not slowing down. It’s exploding. Government is not shrinking. It’s expanding and will keep expanding as more baby boomers retire and start receiving Social Security checks. More and more of life’s decisions are being taken out of the hands of individuals and given to bureaucrats. Those who believe government’s size and scope should be limited are losing. And this is all happening in the supposed heyday of the modern conservative movement and the ascendancy of the Republican Party.

We’re Not Winning Because the Game Is Rigged

Let me remind people: Republicans control the White House, the House, the Senate, 33 governors’ mansions, and 70 of the 99 state legislative chambers. There have been billions invested in the conservative movement over the last few decades. People try to tell me the conservative movement is winning because conservatives dominate talk radio and cable, or because it has never been better-funded. My response: we just look and sound better while getting our tails handed to us. It’s like a basketball team with really nice jerseys and the biggest crowds getting beaten 100 to 43. The spectacle looks nice but the scoreboard is truly embarrassing.

Folks, we don’t need to look better or sound better. We don’t need another radio show or another beautiful think tank building with marble bathrooms. We need to start winning. The reason we’re not is because the game is rigged against us.

That’s right: we’re playing a game where house rules make winning almost impossible. We keep playing it, even though the odds are against us winning, and every time we lose, we shake our fists at the skies and go, “Oh, rats. Foiled again. That’s okay, we’ll win next time.” That’s basically the thought of virtually everyone walking out of a casino, so you’ll be in good company.

Here’s a thought: let’s flip the table and change the rules. Rig them in favor of limited, responsible government. Because seriously, if we don’t bring fundamental change to our government, and just keep exfoliating that elephant of debt, guess what? That elephant, sans a few ounces, is going to land right on our collective heads.

Why Repealing the Seventeenth Will Help

One of the fundamental changes that we need to seriously consider right now: repeal the Seventeenth Amendment. As a reminder: the Seventeenth Amendment allows for the direct election of U.S. senators. Previously, state legislators selected senators. The framers of our Constitution believed this process would make senators less tempted by the whims of voters and more concerned with the long-term interests of their states. Less concerned with the trending topic of the moment, these senators would brake the excesses of government expansion.

The shift towards directly electing U.S. senators severed the ties between states and their senators and destroyed the notion of federalism. Instead of representing their state’s interests in Washington DC, working to advance and protect those interests, there are now 100 little kings roaming Capitol Hill doing their own thing. (In the spirit of generosity, let’s say maybe 90 little kings. There are a few stalwarts fighting the good fight to try and rein in government.)

Do you want governors begging on bended knee for favors from senators? Or do you want senators begging for favors from governors? The seventeenth gave the power to the senators, and subordinated the states to DC. We need to restore the checks and balances.

Imagine if the seventeenth were repealed and senators were beholden to their states, not the DC cabal. Consider that every day lobbyists for any variety of interests are in senators’ offices, many seeking carve-outs or increased spending.

The conversations could be along the lines of: “That carve-out on the spending bill is a lovely idea. However, if I do that, I’ll get ignominiously dragged home and replaced.” Senators would be more inclined to be responsive to state legislators, knowing that this educated, engaged, and empowered electorate watches them more closely than normal voters ever could. (For those who would argue extended vacancies by deadlocked legislatures would be a problem, a 90-day confirmation deadline or else a direct appointment by the governor would keep the process moving.)

By firmly mooring senators once more to their states, the states once again gain power and leverage over DC, giving states more control over their own destiny. Federalism would once again become a fact, not a happy little fiction. Whereas power has been consolidating over the last 100 years in Washington DC, repealing the seventeenth would begin a massive return of power back to the states to be the laboratories of democracy they were designed to be

If President Trump wants to really change the Senate rules, he should start pushing for repealing the Seventeenth Amendment to begin realignment towards lasting, fundamental change.

Ned Ryun is the founder and CEO of American Majority, a non-partisan training institute whose mission is to identify and mold the next wave of liberty-minded new leaders, grassroots activists and community leaders.


Related Posts


  1. Angus Rangus May 13, 2017 at 7:53 AM -  Reply

    OK… actually this has been on OBIWAN’s top ten for over a decade…
    … perhaps just one of the reasons Palm Beach Post and TC Palm-Stuart News eliminated from commenting / cancelled home delivery / cancelled online subscription!!


    Notice when you got 3 or more guests over…
    … casually enjoying Bulgogi / Kimchi / Ice Tea… Beer … Wine… Tequila…
    … you solve most all the problems our DNC – and GOP ‘compromisers’ created during the past 60 years…
    … in one or two paragraphs of simple Easy Engleesh steps …
    … still surviving the 16+ years of Commie Indoctrinashun by the DNC’s Edumucators …
    … decades of rabid progressive liberal loon historical revisionisn by HollyWeird & our DC To Boston Commie Media ??

    Founders had a simple profound reason for ‘states’ having equal representation in that deliberative Senate body – with elected state legislatures selecting WHO that able bodied honest man/woman of integrity and patriotism would be – with full right of recall or impeachment as they deemed worthy of protecting from that Republic!!

    TODAY… career politicians beholding to funding special interests… have destroyed our Republic! We should not have to include a limitation on those ‘state legislatures’ who desire a lifelong tenure of those two – who do that state’s bidding!!

  2. Old Jim May 13, 2017 at 8:08 AM -  Reply

    Anyone registering as or voting the GOP in past decade…

    … should take an hour and review the 2016 GOP Party Platform …
    … that elected that House / Senate Majorities and the White House…

    First… to note few of them are bothering to do squat about any thang contained therein…

    Second… to note what would be possible IF we repeal that 17th Amendment that was such a very b-a-a-d-d-d idea , with GOP now holding 67% of that Senate:

    “” The Seventeenth Amendment, adopted on May 31, 1913, changed the manner in which United States senators were elected. Formerly elected to office by state legislatures, the Seventeenth Amendment provided for a constitutional mandate that United States senators be elected by the popular vote of the citizens of each state.””

    Notice this came from the same group that gave us our first Commie from Princeton … Woodrow Wilson…
    … 16th Amendment created the gestapo IRS and major FIRST BIG LIE of that Federal Income Tax … ONLY being 1% for those few making over $20 K and going to just 7% for those feelthy reech basterds over $500K – rising ten fold in his 8 miserable years…
    … Got us into that first World War… whose inept ending assured the evil identical twins Communism and Fascism would blow the world apart in less than two decades!!

    YEP… we need a BOGO… do away with both…
    … to allow that 15% FLAT Tax to honor privatizing SS & Medicare vested benefits …
    … with a 15% mandatory deposit into Individual Private Accounts – kinda’ like Chile did at 10% back in 1983 – upon reviewing the pending collapse of LBJ’s great LIE – “full faith and credit of the US GOVT”!!…
    … and shuttering the 75% of Federal GOVT lacking any authority for “specific citizen welfare” … only our ‘states’ are sovereign to provide!!

    … and we would make a heartfelt consensus decision within the hour…
    … in time for a nitecap of Grande Marnier!!

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Who's Online

5 visitors online now
0 guests, 5 bots, 0 members


Let's Stay Connected!

If you would like to stay connected an receive email updates about new stories posted you may add your email to our mailing list below. (Email addresses are kept private.)