Hot News - Old, Proud U.S.

Do Republicans Really Work Against Their Constituents’ Interests?

3 13


One paragraph explains it all, what James Shott believes is really happening…

“Republicans, or at least those who are true conservatives, honor the ideals of Liberty, personal responsibility, self-reliance, and limited government, and to a less-than-perfect degree — but a far greater degree than those who call themselves liberals, progressives, or socialists — try to live by these values.”

I believe that what he says is basically true, except for one little thing…There aren’t many “true conservatives” around in the D.C. Swamp anymore.  If there were, our country would already be “great again”!

Great piece James Shott!


It’s not news — not even fake news — that the political Right and the political Left don’t see things the same way; they are different. The Left frequently sees things as problems that the Right doesn’t regard as problems, and vice versa. And even when the two sides agree that something is a problem, they have vastly different ways of addressing it. The gulf between the two factions is arguably wider today than ever before.

The idea that Republican voters sometimes/often vote against their own interests is a Democrat talking point, and this myth was the subject of a recent New York Times podcast. The podcast host, Times managing editor Michael Barbaro, interviewed domestic-affairs correspondent Sheryl Gay Stolberg, who cited the situation in Kentucky, one of the states that suffered mightily when the war on coal put enough people out of work to run Kentucky’s coal jobs to the lowest level in 118 years.

The out-of-work miners, forced onto Medicaid by the war on coal, benefited greatly from ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion, Stolberg said, “yet, its Republican senators are leading the charge for ObamaCare repeal, including for Medicaid reform. How can that be?”

The answer to that question comes from the different ways of looking at the world and at life from opposite sides of the political spectrum.

Which of the following sets of ideas do you most closely observe?

The nuclear family is an antiquated idea, traditional ideas of morality and culture are oppressive, sexual autonomy is a virtue, and we just can’t get by without government “help.”

We graduate from high school and possibly college, find a job to sustain ourselves, marry, and then have children and raise a family.

If you chose 1, you almost certainly lean toward the political Left; if you chose 2, you likely lean toward the political Right. These different views of how to live our lives define why Republicans vote against what seem to be their “interests.”

“Now, between the two parties, which one has centered its appeal around married parents with kids and which party has doubled down on single moms?” National Review’s David French asks. “Even worse, the Democrats’ far-left base has intentionally attacked the nuclear family as archaic and patriarchal. It has celebrated sexual autonomy as a cardinal virtue. Then, when faced with the fractured families that result, it says, ‘Here, let the government help.’”

How does this relate to Kentucky’s Republican senators? They’re voting on their ideas of what makes America great, and according to French, those interests “depend on the complex interplay between our faith, our families, and our communities.” It’s all about core values.

New York Times columnist David Brooks traces these values back to American frontier towns, where life was “fragile, perilous, lonely and remorseless,” and where a “single slip could produce disaster.” As a result, the frontier folk learned to practice “self-restraint, temperance, self-control and strictness of conscience.”

Those values are at the heart of the American experience of carving a powerful and free republic out of a wilderness, a nation that has as a result led the world for decades. They reflect the Biblical values brought here and cultivated during America’s first turbulent and troubled decades, and which formed the basis of the government created following the “Colexit” of the Colonies from Mother England’s repressive grasp.

Republicans, or at least those who are true conservatives, honor the ideals of Liberty, personal responsibility, self-reliance, and limited government, and to a less-than-perfect degree — but a far greater degree than those who call themselves liberals, progressives, or socialists — try to live by these values.

Kentucky’s Republican senators dislike the government’s solution to the problem that the government itself created when it over-regulated nearly everything, and so they see a vote against maintaining this absurdity as a virtuous one. They prefer a system freeing Americans to make their own decisions about health care and health insurance without the one-size-fits-nobody concept Democrats created that we commonly call ObamaCare.

Their vote seemingly punishes those they should most want to help: their constituents and supporters. But the bigger picture shows instead the desire to free their constituents from the damaging big government policies that put them on the government dole. They want to create an environment where they can find another job that can sustain them above the poverty line, and off of Medicaid.

Republicans want to do away with this Democrat-created problem. Their fundamental goal is to free Americans from this horrible, failed big government mechanism. Democrats’ aim is to ultimately create a single-payer, totally government-controlled health care system that would mirror the British system. You know the one: It recently took control of decisions on seriously ill infant Charlie Gard’s care away from his parents, and effectively ordered Charlie’s death.

That case demonstrates precisely how government-run health care will degenerate into death panels — a system where government makes decisions about who lives and dies based on numbers on a spreadsheet. And that explains why Republicans seem to vote against their constituents’ interests. They’re not voting against them at all, but for their Liberty.


Related Posts


  1. Uniwersity of Barsoom at Helium Edumukashun Xspurt July 12, 2017 at 6:10 AM -  Reply


    Hmmm… Ted Cruz and Mike Lee and a few others in the Senate advertising as TRUE… conservatives / libertarians / originalists / TEA Party…

    … EACH has offered ‘amendments’ to BARAMACare Replacement…

    … despite endorsing the 2016 GOP Party Platform of REPEAL EVERY WORD!!

    How simply can you agree with the 4 SCOTUS Justices who could find NO authority for our Federal GOVT…
    … not simply state that at every opportunity to force a REPEAL EVERY WORD vote in that same ‘collegial’ body??

    FREE STUFF… the quid pro quo of even an ‘honest’ TRUE …
    … to raise enuff campaign funds to make even a single term!!

  2. Angus Rangus July 12, 2017 at 6:17 AM -  Reply


    FLAT TAX… with no exemptions or ‘fair’ refunds of any kind…

    Consider how simple Payroll Taxes SHOULD be…

    … Employers and Employees pay equal portions of a fixed % – to fund actuarial determined benefits for self-liquidating perpetuity in Trust.

    HOW did we bastardize this simple concept from the getgo…
    … by not actually depositing but GOVT IOU’s into a box or computer accounting?
    … by changing how high those feelthy reech bastards must pay in – and still get no benefits?
    … by allowing pre-application in paychecks of those paying ZERO in FIT with scams of ‘Refundable Tax Credits”?

    … and REFUSING for the past 40 years to even discuss FIXING the beyond repair bankruptcy of this by the only real answer… PRIVATIZATION.

    The US has the world class Pension and Insurance industries…
    … and we kick them to the curb to avoid the realities they bring??

  3. Old Jim July 12, 2017 at 6:22 AM -  Reply

    THEY all endorsed the 2016 GOP Party Platform…

    … they all got FB and all the other Sheeple Commie Zombie twittering / et al…

    … they all brag daily about thangs they will get you from the DC Money Laundry!!

    Here’s the acid test of abject miserable failure:

    1. Feds spend 3 cents minting a penny…?

    2. Feds can’t round off that .9 cents per gallon … when a penny is worthless anyway??

    AND we got the ‘nerve’ to comment on those ONLINE SS and Medicare portals…


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Who's Online

4 visitors online now
0 guests, 4 bots, 0 members


Let's Stay Connected!

If you would like to stay connected an receive email updates about new stories posted you may add your email to our mailing list below. (Email addresses are kept private.)